Dogtra 1900S Vs. Garmin Sport PRO: Which Dog Collar Is Best?

Published by

Matthew William

For many dog owners, using an electronic training collar can be a great way to reinforce commands and desired behaviors. Two popular options on the market are the Dogtra 1900S and the Garmin Sport PRO. But with different features and capabilities, which one is the better choice?

This detailed comparison examines the pros and cons of each model to help you decide.

A Brief Comparison Table

Feature	Dogtra 1900S	Garmin Sport PRO
*Range*	1/2 mile	1 mile
*Stimulation Levels*	100	21
*Waterproof*	Yes	Yes
*Battery Life*	40-50 hrs	40-60 hrs
*Max Dogs Supported*	3	3
*Tone Options*	Standard	Standard + Beep
*Collar Fit*	5 lbs+	8 lbs+
*Price*	$300+	$200+

Overview Of The Dogtra 1900S

The Dogtra 1900S is a reliable training collar with a 1/2 mile range. It has both shock and vibration modes and can support up to 3 dogs at once with additional receivers.

Dogtra 1900S

Some key features and specs:

1/2 mile range
Rechargeable lithium polymer battery
100 levels of static stimulation
High/medium/low stimulation modes
Vibration and tone modes
Fully waterproof collar and receiver
2 hour fast charge
Collar fit for dogs 5+ pounds

The Dogtra uses patented technology to deliver precise stimulation levels so you can tailor the shock level for your dog. It has a slim, ergonomic transmitter that is easy to operate. The OLED screen clearly displays stimulation level and battery life.

Multiple dogs can be controlled with the purchase of extra receivers/collars. The transmitter can switch between signals seamlessly so you don’t need separate remote controls.

Overview Of The Garmin Sport PRO

Garmin Sport PRO

The Garmin Sport PRO features a 1 mile range and also offers both vibration and static stimulation. It can support up to 3 dogs as well.

Key specs and features:

1 mile range
Rechargeable battery
21 levels of static stimulation
Tone and vibration modes
Waterproof and submersible
Resistive touch panel transmitter
OLED display shows stimulation level and battery life
Light mode for night training

The Sport PRO has a simpler, more streamlined transmitter compared to the Dogtra. The touch buttons allow you to quickly change settings. An LED light band aids with visibility.

This collar/remote system can also expand to control up to 3 dogs at once with additional purchases. The transmitter automatically identifies which dog is receiving signals.

Dogtra 1900S Pros

Finely adjustable stimulation – With 100 levels, you can precisely tailor the stimulation intensity to your dog’s needs. This allows more customizable training.
Longer range – The 1/2 mile range gives you more flexibility in wide open spaces or trails.
Slimmer transmitter design – The remote control fits nicely in your hand and can slip easily into a pocket. The small profile makes it great for those with smaller hands too.
Stimulation precedes tone – When using both tone and stimulation, the Dogtra collar issues the stimulation first instead of a warning tone. This allows for more timely corrections.
Faster charge time – The collar and transmitter charge up in just 2 hours, so you can get back to training quickly.

Garmin Sport PRO Pros

Simpler transmitter – With just one button and a touch panel, the remote control is very intuitive and easy to operate even with gloves on.
Larger dog fit – While the Dogtra collar suits dogs 5 pounds and up, the Sport PRO claims to fit dogs 8 pounds and larger.
More tone options – Garmin’s collar offers both a standard tone and a “beep” tone for variation. This provides more flexibility when marker training.
Vibration precedes tone – The vibrations acts as a “warning” before a tone sounds and stimulation occurs. This may work better for some dogs when conditioning behaviors.
Battery life indicator – LEDs on the collar provide a quick visual check of remaining battery life. Handy for when you’re on the go.

Dogtra 1900S Cons

Higher price – The Dogtra system retails around $300 depending on packages, while the Garmin Sport PRO costs closer to $200.
Larger transmitter – While ergonomic, the Dogtra remote is bigger than the Garmin model. For those with small hands/pockets, it may be overly bulky.
Lower stimulation range – With only 100 levels, the Dogtra doesn’t offer as fine of adjustments as collars with over 100 levels. Precision is somewhat limited.
Shorter battery life – Run time caps out around 40-50 hours per charge depending on use. Frequent training sessions may require more regular charging.

Garmin Sport PRO Cons

Shorter range – At just 1 mile, the Garmin’s range is limited compared to the 1/2 mile range of the Dogtra system. Not ideal for wide open hiking/hunting.
Fewer stimulation levels – With only 21 levels, the precision in “dialing in” the right stimulation amount for your dog is decreased.
No separate tone button – The transmitter lacks a dedicated tone button, so you have to switch modes frequently if using tones alone.
Collar only package – Garmin doesn’t offer packages bundling additional collars/receivers, so adding dogs gets costly.

Also watch the video about Garmin Sport PRO!

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Which is better dogtra Vs. SportDOG?

Both Dogtra and SportDOG make high quality dog training collars with similar features. Key differences are:
Dogtra offers more stimulation levels (100 Vs. 21) for finer precision
SportDOG has a longer range of 3/4 mile
Dogtra uses lithium polymer batteries while SportDOG uses lithium ion
SportDOG packages come with extra collars and receivers for multiple dogs
Dogtra edges out SportDOG for its wider stimulation range, but both are excellent brands.

What is the best remote dog training collar?

The best remote dog training collars balance functionality, effectiveness, and safety. Top rated models include:
Dogtra 1900S – Reliable stimulation and 1/2 mile range
Garmin Sport PRO – Intuitive simplicity and solid performance
PetSafe Elite – Affordable but still has needed features
Educator E-Collar – Highly customizable with great range
Mini Educator – For small dogs down to 5 lbs
Focus on a good fit for your dog’s size, temperament and your training needs. Avoid extremely cheap models.

What is the on button on dogtra 1900s?

The Dogtra 1900S transmitter has two buttons on the face – a black button and an orange button.
The black button serves as the “on” button to power the remote on and off. Holding it briefly will turn the transmitter on or off.
The orange button is used during training to activate stimulation and cycle through the different stimulation levels. The black button turns everything on, while the orange button controls stimulation delivery.

How long does Garmin Sport Pro last?

The Garmin Sport PRO remote collar system offers 40-60 hours of battery life per charge depending on use. At high stimulation levels, you’ll get closer to 40 hours of run time. For shorter, less frequent sessions, the battery duration will be longer.
Frequent users should expect to charge the Sport PRO transmitter and collar about once a week. Quick charges can add extra life in a pinch. Like all rechargeables, the battery life will eventually decrease over time after years of use.

The Verdict

In the end, both the Dogtra 1900S and Garmin Sport PRO represent quality, full-featured electronic collars that are top contenders for effective dog training.

Key factors in choosing between them include your budget, training environment, and number of dogs. Dogtra’s wider stimulation range offers more fine tuning, but the Garmin system is more affordable and has a simpler transmitter.

Take stock of your specific needs and your dog’s temperament to determine which model is the right fit. Either way, be sure to introduce the stimulation properly through conditioning to create an effective correction tool rather than relying on punishment.