Freemie Vs. Elvie: Which Wearable Breast Pump Is Best?

Wearable breast pumps have revolutionized pumping for nursing mothers by offering more freedom and mobility than traditional pumps. Two of the most popular wearable pumps on the market are the Freemie Freedom and Elvie Pump. But which one is the better choice?

This detailed comparison of Freemie and Elvie wearable pumps will examine the key features, pros and cons, and real user experiences to help you decide which pump best meets your needs and budget.

Comparison Chart

Pump Features	Freemie Freedom	Elvie Pump
Type	Electric, wearable	Electric, wearable
Suction Levels	8 (16 – 250 mmHg)	5 (70 – 180 mmHg)
Maximum Suction	250 mmHg	180 mmHg
Battery Life	Up to 2 hours	Up to 2 hours
Weight	10.6 oz	7 oz
Noise Level	Audible pumping sounds	Nearly silent
Milk Storage	Requires bottles/bags	Internal up to 10 oz
App/Tracking	None	Yes, monitors session
Cost	$199-$289	$499

Overview Of Freemie And Elvie Pumps

The Freemie Freedom and Elvie Pump are both closed system, wireless, hands-free pumps meant to be worn inside your bra for more discreet and convenient pumping anytime, anywhere. Here is a quick rundown of each pump:

Freemie Freedom

• Single or double electric pump
• 8 adjustable suction levels
• Rechargeable battery lasts up to 2 hours
• Comes with cups, tubing, and removable spout valves
• Compatible with wide range of bottle brands
• Can purchase extra parts like larger flanges separately
• Typically costs $199-299 depending on single or double pump

Elvie Pump

• Silent wearable double electric pump
• 5 adjustable suction levels
• Rechargeable battery lasts up to 2 hours
• Internal milk containers hold up to 5oz each
• Connects to app to monitor pumping
• All-in-one closed system, no extra parts needed
• Retails for $499

Both pumps aim to provide a portable and subtle way to pump whenever you need. But there are some key differences that may make one better suited for your individual needs.

Pumping Power And Performance

A critical factor in choosing a breast pump is its strength and effectiveness at extracting milk. Here is how the Freemie and Elvie pumps compare:

• Suction range: The Freemie has 8 adjustable suction levels ranging from 16 to 250mmHg. The Elvie has 5 levels ranging from 70 to 180mmHg. The Freemie offers a wider range of suction power up to a maximum of 250mmHg.
• Suction strength: At their highest settings, the Freemie has stronger suction power. Users report the Freemie being able to fully empty their breasts per session.
• Milk output: Many users get comparable milk output from both pumps. However, some users noticed less milk output with the Elvie pump.
• Efficiency: The Freemie is a standard electric pump with tubing and valves like a traditional pump, so it operates efficiently. The Elvie pump operates direct from the base without tubing, which may reduce efficiency for some users.

For mothers who need strong suction to efficiently drain their breasts, the Freemie Freedom may be the better choice.

Portability And Discretion

A major appeal of wearable pumps is their portability and discretion for pumping on the go. Here is how they compare in these areas:

• Size: Both pumps are lightweight and compact. The Elvie pump is a bit smaller since it’s an all-in-one and fits inside a bra cup.
• Noise: The Elvie pump is almost silent so very discreet. The Freemie pump has faint electric pumping sounds that some users feel are noticeable.
• Concealment: Since the Elvie is an enclosed system with no external tubes or bottles, it is very concealed under clothes for pumping in public. The Freemie requires tubing and a bottle/bag attachment which can be seen through clothes.
• Portability: The lack of external tubing also makes the Elvie a bit more portable and easy to move around in. The Freemie pump requires carrying the tubes and milk collection system.

If absolute subtlety and mobility are your top concerns, the Elvie pump has a slight edge for pumping on the go discreetly. But the Freemie still offers good portability.

Also Read: Freemie Vs. Legendairy Cups: Comparing Features, Pros & Cons

Ease Of Use And Comfort

Convenience and comfort are also important factors for breast pumps. Here is how Freemie and Elvie compare:

• Fit: Both pumps fit inside standard nursing bra cups. The Elvie is an all-in-one so requires no separate attachments. Some users find the Elvie cups run small while Freemie fits most bra sizes.
• Setup: The Elvie pump is ready to pump out of the box. The Freemie requires assembly of the tubing, valves, milk collection bottles/bags. This makes the Elvie a bit simpler to get started.
• Cleaning: The Freemie has more parts (tubing, valves, bottles) that require cleaning after each use which is more work. The Elvie is self-contained so easier to clean.
• Operation: The Elvie pump turns on/off and controls suction from the device. The Freemie controls suction from a separate remote. Some users find the remote less convenient than on-device controls.
• Comfort: Both pumps use soft silicone flanges to reduce irritation. Some users find the Freemie valves inside bra cups uncomfortable. Overall users find both pumps comfortable for extended wear.

For maximum simplicity and ease of use, the Elvie pump has an advantage. But the Freemie is still relatively easy to use, especially once you get the hang of setup and cleaning.

Battery Life And Features

The battery life and special features also differentiate these pumps:

• Battery: Both pumps have rechargeable batteries lasting up to 2 hours per charge. The Elvie may lose suction over time as its battery depletes. The Freemie maintains consistent suction until the battery dies.
• Milk storage: The Elvie pump has internal milk storage containers that each hold up to 5oz. The Freemie requires attaching milk collection bags or bottles.
• App/Monitor: The Elvie connects to an app to monitor pumping sessions and milk volume in real-time. The Freemie does not have an app or monitoring display.
• Extra parts: The Freemie allows buying larger flange sizes, extended tubing, and other accessories to customize fit. The Elvie is only available in standard sizing.

The Elvie’s integrated milk storage and app connectivity make it more of a “smart” pump. But the Freemie offers more flexibility with parts to customize fit.

Cost Comparison

The cost of these pumps is another major difference:

• Freemie: $199 for single pump, $289 for double pump
• Elvie: $499 for double pump bundle

Buying a Freemie single or double pump costs significantly less than the Elvie. However, the Elvie is an all-in-one system while the Freemie requires separate purchases of bottles, bags, etc.

For anyone on a tight budget, the more affordable Freemie pumps may fit better. The Elvie is a premium pump with higher costs.

Also watch the review of Elvie Pump!

Real User Experiences

Looking at real customer reviews reveals how these pumps perform in everyday use:

Freemie User Feedback

• Strong suction empties breasts per session
• Takes time to get setup right with valves and tubing
• Remote, not in-bra controls less convenient
• Bottles can leak if not attached properly
• Affordable price point with frequent sales/discounts

Elvie User Feedback

• Very quiet and discreet
• Simple to use with no setup required
• App and tracking milk volume helpful
• Need to pump upright to get maximum output
• Small flange size doesn’t fit all women
• Expensive price tag

Overall both pumps receive positive feedback, with the Freemie praised for its strength and affordability and the Elvie praised for its discreetness and convenience. But each pump also comes with minor frustrations according to users.

FAQs

Also Read: Legendairy Milk Liquid Gold Vs. Pump Princess: Best Supplement

Conclusion And Recommendation

When choosing between the Freemie Freedom and Elvie wearable breast pump, consider these key factors:

Pumping power – Freemie is stronger

Portability – Elvie is more discreet

Ease of use – Elvie is simpler

Price – Freemie is more budget-friendly

The Freemie tends to be the best choice for moms who:

• Need maximum milk output and pumping efficiency
• Have a tighter budget
• Don’t mind about tubing/bottles showing through clothes

The Elvie tends to be ideal for moms who:

• Highly prioritize subtle, mobile pumping
• Appreciate the tracking and smart features
• Are willing to pay more for convenience

For many moms, the more affordable Freemie pump will meet their needs. But the Elvie is fantastic for discretion and simplicity if you can afford the $499 price. Both pumps make wearable pumping far more feasible and comfortable compared to standard pumps.

In Summary

Wearable breast pumps like Freemie and Elvie provide nursing mothers much more freedom and flexibility for pumping milk whenever needed. Both pumps have excellent features and performance. For moms who need maximum milk output or are on a budget, the Freemie Freedom is an excellent choice starting at just $199. But for those seeking the ultimate subtlety and tracking/tech features, the innovative Elvie pump is worth the $499 investment.

Carefully weigh your personal priorities and needs to decide if the Freemie or Elvie wearable pump is the better fit for you. Whichever you choose, you can pump confidently and comfortably while maintaining your active lifestyle.