Metal Shed Vs. Plastic Shed: Which is Better for Your Backyard?

When it comes to storage sheds, homeowners have two main options – metal or plastic. Both have their pros and cons when it comes to durability, appearance, cost, and ease of installation.

This comprehensive guide examines the key differences between metal and plastic sheds to help you decide which is better for your needs.

Feature	Metal Shed	Plastic Shed
Durability	Very durable, can last 20+ years	Less durable, lasts 10-15 years
Appearance	Industrial look, available in various colors	Clean, modern look, limited color options
Cost	More expensive upfront	Cheaper upfront costs
Assembly	Requires professional installation	Easy DIY assembly
Maintenance	Prone to rusting and denting	Low maintenance
Customization	Limited size and style options	Fully customizable sizes and styles

When choosing between a metal or plastic shed, the main factors to consider are durability, appearance, cost, assembly, maintenance, and customization options. Metal sheds are extremely durable, while plastic sheds have a shorter lifespan.

Metal sheds have an industrial look, while plastic sheds offer a cleaner, more modern aesthetic. Plastic sheds are cheaper upfront, but metal sheds have lower long-term costs. Plastic sheds can be easily assembled by DIYers, but metal sheds require professional installation.

Maintenance needs vary, with metal being more prone to rust and dents. And plastic sheds offer full customization, while metal sheds have limited options.

Advantages And Disadvantages Of Metal Sheds

Pros:

• Extremely durable and long-lasting, can survive over 20 years
• Withstands all weather conditions – rain, snow, wind, etc.
• Sturdy and secure against theft and vandalism
• Available in wide range of sizes to fit needs
• Industrial appearance blends into yards
• Can match color with home for consistency

Cons:

• Very heavy, requiring professional installation
• Can be prone to rusting and denting over time
• More expensive upfront costs compared to plastic sheds
• Limited size and style options for customization
• Can conduct heat in hot climates
• May require frequent repainting to prevent rust

Metal sheds are the standard choice for many homeowners due to their rugged durability and security. High quality steel sheds can withstand decades of harsh weather conditions while deterring potential break-ins.

Their heavyweight construction requires professional installation for proper assembly. While expensive initially, a metal shed will last for years with proper maintenance to prevent rusting. Just be aware that metal can dent easily, conduct heat, and offer limited customization compared to plastic sheds.

Advantages And Disadvantages Of Plastic Sheds

Pros:

• Low maintenance and rustproof construction
• Resists denting and scratching better than metal
• Cooler temperature inside shed during hot weather
• Fully customizable sizes, styles and colors
• Modern and clean aesthetic for yards
• DIY friendly assembly, no professional needed
• Cheaper upfront costs compared to metal sheds

Cons:

• Less durable than metal, lasts 10-15 years
• Not as sturdy or secure as metal sheds
• Can fade and discolor over time
• More prone to damage from high winds
• Limited color options compared to metal
• May require anchoring to prevent blowing over

Plastic resin sheds offer many benefits that make them a popular choice for easy, customized storage. Their all-weather construction holds up well against sun, rain, and snow without rusting. Plastic resists denting better than metal, keeping a pristine appearance.

Homeowners can choose custom colors, sizes, windows, and doors for a shed that matches their needs. A plastic shed provides cooler storage in hot climates. While not as durable as metal sheds, high quality plastic can last over a decade with proper anchoring.

Just watch out for excessive sun damage, be prepared for some DIY maintenance, and take precautions to prevent blowing over in high winds.

Also watch this video!

Key Factors To Consider When Choosing A Shed

• Intended purpose – Will it be used for garden tools, pool equipment, outdoor furniture, etc? Metal works well for heavy equipment while plastic suits general storage.
• Size and dimensions – Measure available space in yard and purchase a shed that fits without overwhelming. Allow space to access doors/windows.
• Local building codes – Many areas have codes for shed size, location, doors, etc. Check with your local permit office before purchasing.
• Appearance – Metal has an industrial vibe while plastic is clean and modern. Choose a look that matches your home.
• Weather conditions – If dealing with heavy snowfall, high winds or corrosive coastal air, metal sheds are more durable.
• Budget – Plastic sheds are cheaper at initial purchase but may require earlier replacement compared to pricier metal sheds.
• Ease of installation – Those able to handle DIY assembly will appreciate modular plastic sheds versus hiring professional metal shed installers.
• Maintenance – Metal requires frequent touch up painting and rust prevention while plastic just needs occasional cleaning.
• Security – Metal sheds provide more secure storage for valuables. Plastic sheds can be anchored for stability but won’t deter break ins like metal.

Carefully evaluating your needs and yard restrictions will ensure you select the right shed for your specific situation. Weigh durability, costs, appearance, weather, codes, and installation needs when deciding between metal and plastic.

Also Read: Comparison Between Levolor And Allen & Roth Faux Wood Blinds.

Shopping Smart – What To Look For In A Quality Shed

When comparing options, here are key indicators of a well-built, long-lasting shed:

Metal Sheds:

• 14+ gauge steel construction
• Rust-resistant galvanized steel
• Secure locking doors with tamper-proof hinges
• Durable paint/powder coating
• Secure roof panels and water-tight seals
• Gravel or wood foundation
• Ventilation for air flow

Plastic Sheds:

• Thick, weather-resistant polyethylene panels
• Steel reinforced flooring and roofing
• UV protection against sun damage
• Vented panels prevent condensation and fogging
• Modular cam-lock assembly for easy DIY building
• Anchoring hardware to secure to ground
• Doors that seal tightly when closed

Avoid cheaply made sheds with thin steel, weak structural supports, and poor UV protection if longevity is important. Paying more upfront for quality materials will help your shed last for many years in harsh outdoor storage conditions.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Also Read: Choose Between Flat And Dome Skylight.

Conclusion

When selecting outdoor storage, weigh your specific needs and yard considerations before choosing between metal and plastic sheds. Metal sheds provide rugged durability and security but require professional assembly and frequent maintenance.

For customizable style and easy DIY building, plastic sheds are an affordable option though less robust. Ensure you purchase quality materials, check local codes, and prepare your site appropriately for the best long-term shed performance. With the right choice and proper care, your new shed can provide years of reliable backyard storage.